Great Food. Cold Beer. Indianapolis Tradition.
Location
Come Visit Us!
5650 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46278-1301, United States
(317) 334-1226
Hours
Monday: 11AM - 12AM
Tuesday: 11AM - 12AM
Wednesday: 11AM - 12AM
Thursday: 11AM - 12AM
Friday: 11AM - 1AM
Saturday: 11AM - 1AM
Sunday: 11AM - 1AM
Welcome to Trader’s Mill
At Traders Mill Bar & Grill, we believe every great neighborhood deserves a place where people can relax, connect, and enjoy outstanding food. From handcrafted burgers and crispy wings to fresh salads and daily specials, we serve the flavors Indianapolis loves. Pair your meal with a local craft beer, signature cocktail, or your favorite draft, and you'll quickly see why guests keep coming back.
Our Food Menu
SALADS
CAESAR SALAD
Romaine lettuce with shaved parmesan and croutons tossed with Caesar dressing 5.99 - Entrée with Chicken 13.49
CHEF SALAD
Swiss cheese, ham, bacon, turkey, tomatoes, red onions, chopped egg, mushrooms and black olives atop fresh greens 14.99
BLACK & BLEU SALAD
Thinly sliced USDA choice sirloin steak cooked to order, bleu cheese crumbles, tomatoes, and onions atop fresh greens 16.99
GRILLED CHICKEN BLT SALAD
Two crispy fried green tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, feta cheese, diced red tomatoes and green onions atop fresh greens 14.99
CHICKEN DELUXE SALAD
Grilled or fried chicken, cheese, tomatoes, onion, egg and mushrooms atop fresh greens 14.99
SALMON SALAD
Grilled salmon with feta cheese, black olives, tomatoes and onions atop fresh greens 16.99
GYRO SALAD
Gyro meat, tomato, onion and tzatziki sauce atop iceberg lettuce 13.99
DRESSINGS
Ranch, Bleu Cheese, French, Italian, Caesar, 1000 Island, Chipotle Ranch, Honey Mustard, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Oil & Vinegar
STARTERS
APPETIZER SAMPLER
Loaded Potato Skins, Garlic Knots, Fried Cheese, Boneless Wings, 2 oz. Buffalo Chicken Dip and Tortilla Chips. Includes choice of dressings, sour cream and marinara for dipping 17.99
LOADED FRIES OR POTATO SKINS
A mound of French fries or potato skins topped with melted cheese, bacon, jalapeños and chives served with ranch or sour cream on the side 10.99
Add Chopped Tomatoes, Extra Bacon, Mushrooms or Sliced Jalapeños 1.50
CHICKEN OR STEAK QUESADILLA
Grilled chicken or seasoned steak bites packed into a soft flour tortilla with melted cheese, tomatoes and red onions served with sour cream and salsa on the side. Chicken 11.99 • Steak 13.99
FRIED MUSHROOMS
Mushrooms hand breaded and seasoned to perfection. Served with ranch or chipotle ranch 11.99
FINGER LICKIN WINGS
Boneless or traditional Chicken wings tossed to order in Buffalo, Teriyaki, Bourbon, BBQ, Spicy Plum, or Jamaican Jerk sauce.
8 Wings 16.99 • 12 Wings 19.99
GARLIC KNOTS
Hand tied fresh dough knots fried golden tossed in garlic butter and topped with parmesan cheese and served with marinara 8.99
Add jalapeño queso 1.50
HUMMUS PLATE
Ground chickpeas, tahini, extra virgin olive oil served with pita bread 9.99
FLAT FRIED PICKLES
Fresh whole pickles sliced by hand, hand-breaded and fried golden 10.99
LOADED CHICKEN OR CHILI NACHOS
Chopped grilled chicken or beef with jalapeño queso, tomatoes, lettuce and red onions atop crunchy tortilla chips 11.99 • Extra Queso 1.50
BUFFALO CHICKEN DIP & CHIPS
House-made Buffalo dip made with cream cheese and our grilled chicken shredded by hand served with fresh chips 9.99
DEEP-FRIED FRESH MOZZARELLA
100% fresh, never frozen hand cut, breaded and fried crunchy mozzarella sticks. Served with marinara sauce for dipping 11.99
CAJUN STEAK BITES
An appetizer portion of filet steak bites and fresh tomatoes Cajun seasoned and served with a side of ranch or chipotle ranch dressing 13.99
SANDWICHES
Served with choice of one side
Add Additional Toppings for .75 each
CLUB SANDWICH
Fresh turkey and ham, applewood smoked bacon, red onion, Swiss cheese, tomato and romaine lettuce on thick-sliced, grilled white or wheat bread 13.99
ULTIMATE B.L.T.
Applewood smoked bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato and mayo served on hearty grilled white or wheat bread 10.99
TENDERLOIN SANDWICH
Best in Indianapolis! Open flame grilled or hand-breaded and fried pork tenderloin with lettuce and red onion on a brioche bun 15.99 TRY THREE LITTLE PIGS STYLE Add ham, applewood-smoked bacon, and sliced provolone +$2
REUBEN
Thinly sliced corned beef with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and 1000 island dressing served on marbled rye 14.99
GRILLED OR CAJUN CHICKEN
Flamed grilled simplicity - lean and tasty - with lettuce and onion 12.99. Kick it up with Cajun seasoning and pepper jack cheese 1.50
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH
Crispy breaded chicken bathed in zingy Buffalo sauce, lettuce and onion on a brioche bun 12.99
CHIPOTLE BREADED CHICKEN SANDWICH
Crispy breaded chicken topped Swiss cheese, lettuce and onion with chipotle ranch on a brioche bun 13.99
CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP
Stuffed with grilled or crispy chicken, romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing 11.99
SOUTHWEST TURKEY WRAP
Sliced turkey, lettuce, pepper jack cheese, tomato, jalapeño, tortilla strips and chipotle ranch dressing for a nice kick 11.99
CHICKEN WRAP
Grilled or crispy chicken with lettuce, tomato, onion, cheese and ranch dressing 11.99. Jerk or Buffalo Style +99¢
SPECIALTY GYRO
Beef and lamb mix served open-faced on a pita topped with tomatoes, white onions and tzatziki sauce 9.99 • With French Fries 12.99
CHICKEN STRIPS
Golden fried boneless chicken breast in thick-cut strips on a bed of French fries and choice of dipping sauce 14.99 • Buffalo Style .99
FABULOUS FISH & CHIPS
Hand-dipped filets of cod in our homemade fresh beer batter on a bed of golden French fries 13.99
Sides
FRENCH FRIES
COLE SLAW
TORTILLA CHIPS
SIDE SALAD
SEASONAL VEGETABLE
COTTAGE CHEESE
KETTLE CHIPS
RICE PILAF
CAJUN COIN FRIES (ADD 1.49)
ONION RINGS (ADD 1.49)
SWEET POTATO FRIES (ADD 1.49)
CUP OF SOUP OR CHILI (ADD 1.49)
BAKED POTATO (After 5 PM)
GREEN BEANS WITH BACON
(After 5 PM)
Steaks & Kabobs
All steaks are USDA Choice perfectly seasoned, grilled-to-order, with a choice of two sides.
We recommend the baked potato with sour cream and butter!
FILET MIGNON 24.99
NEW YORK STRIP 23.99
RIBEYE FILET 24.99
SALMON - Choice of grilled or sautéed - 22.99
TUESDAY Steak Specials (at 5PM) 20.99
$1 OFF Breaded Tenderloin
SATURDAY Steak Specials (at 5PM) 20.99
STEAK KABOB
Grilled Steak with vegetables over a bed of rice, with hummus and pita bread. 24.99
Classic Burgers
Served with choice of one side
CHEESEBURGER
1/2 pound seasoned, flame-grilled to order patty topped the way you like it our choice of cheese: Cheddar • Provolone • Pepper Jack American • Swiss • Mozzarella • Feta • Bleu Cheese - 16.49
MUSHROOM SWISS BURGER
Sautéed mushrooms and Swiss cheese 16.49
BUILD YOUR OWN BURGER
Served with red onion and lettuce. Optional toppings: pickles or tomatoes. 16.49
Bread Options: Brioche bun • White • Wheat • Rye
50¢ Each: Jalapeños • Green Peppers • Olives • Fresh Mushrooms
$1.50 Each: Extra Cheese or Queso • Feta • Grilled Onions • Grilled Mushrooms • Chopped Egg • Bacon • Add Fried Egg +2
Pizzas
Your choice of traditional or thin crust. 12" or 16"
MEAT LOVERS
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, and fresh mozzarella
12" 17.99 - 16"21.99
THE WORKS
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, onion, mushroom, green pepper, black olives, and fresh mozzarella
12" 17.99 - 16" 21.99
VEGGIE
Green peppers, onion, mushrooms, black olives, and fresh mozzarella
12"16.99 - 16"19.99
BBQ CHICKEN
Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce (instead of marinara), sliced red onions, and fresh mozzarella
12” 16.99 - 16” 20.99
BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA
Your choice of traditional or thin crust.
12"Cheese 14.99 or 16" 16.99
TOPPINGS .75 Each
Mushrooms • Chopped or Sliced Tomatoes• Chopped or Sliced Red Onion • Jalapeños • Green Peppers • Grilled White Onions • Chopped Garlic • Cilantro • Pepperoni • Sausage • Ham Bacon • Turkey • Extra Mozzarella• Colby Jack• American • Swiss • Pepper Jack • Cheddar
PREMIUM TOPPINGS 2.00 Each
Feta • Buffalo Chicken Dip • Jalapeño Queso • Bleu Cheese
Desserts
CLASSIC CHEESECAKE 7.99
BOURBON PECAN PIE 7.99
TRIPLE CHOCOLATE CAKE 7.99
BROWNIE 7.99
BROWNIE SUNDAE 7.99
Add chocolate sauce, caramel sauce, and/or whipped cream to any dessert free!
BEVERAGES
Full Bar
Draft, craft, and traditional beers, an expansive selection of imaginative cocktails, and a diverse, thoughtfully curated wine list covering international and domestic favorites.
Sodas with Refills
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Mountain Dew, Dr. Pepper, Mug Root Beer, Sweet Iced Tea, Iced Tea, Lemonade, Soda Water, Tonic Water - 2.99
ORANGE JUICE, CRANBERRY, PINEAPPLE, MILK - 3.00
RED BULL - A variety of flavors or sugar free 4.99
Non-Alcoholic
Draft, craft, and traditional beers, an expansive selection of imaginative cocktails, and a diverse, thoughtfully curated wine list covering international and domestic favorites.
